Skip to main content

7 Indications You’re About to Make a Really Bad Leadership Decision

Have you ever made a bad decision in leadership? Of course, we all have. It is actually part of the way we grow as leaders. I’ve made many bad decisions in my leadership.

Thankfully, the longer I lead, the more I have developed some warning signs I’m about to make another. There are certain indicators which help me pinpoint a potential bad leadership decision – even before I pull the trigger on it.

Please understand, these aren’t full proof. They don’t mean you are definitely making a bad decision. For those of us who are followers of Christ, we know sometimes what God calls us to do will not make sense to anyone at first.

But there are things we do everyday as leaders not clearly spelled out in Scripture or things God hasn’t specifically instructed us to do or not do. (For pushback on that statement I always like to ask pastors something like when/where God told them the details of how to pave and stripe their church parking lot – or whether to print a church bulletin.)

For the many leadership decisions we make where there isn’t a clearly defined answer, here are a few hints you might be making a bad leadership decision. I believe they are worth considering.

7 indications you’re about to make a bad leadership decision:

The decision makes everyone happy.

Chances are you are settling for less than best if everyone is happy. The best decisions almost never please everyone. They involve change and sacrifice. Change is uncomfortable for someone – always – and seldom universally accepted.

This doesn’t mean you don’t attempt to bring the most people into agreement with the change. If you don’t you won’t have followers for long. But you should base the final decision not as much on what is popular as much as what is right. This requires the hard work of leadership.

It’s an easy decision.

Some decisions are. Most aren’t. Especially major decisions. The hard decisions require prayer, wrestling through the options, and collaborating with others.  Making hard decisions is actually where we need leadership most. If everything is easy you don’t really need a leader.

You are making the decision alone.

Plans fail for the lack of counsel. With many counselors plans succeed. (Proverbs 15:22) I’ve seldom regretted my decision, even when it doesn’t turn out as I might have wished, if I know I have invited others into the decision-making process. There is a certain comfort in shared ownership.

This doesn’t mean I don’t have to stand alone at times, but not without first consulting people I trust. (For a great example of these, see how David allowed his men to speak into a decision in 1 Samuel 23:1-5)

You are going against your closest advisors .

Not only do I need to invite others into the decision-making process, I need to heed the people’s advice I invite. This is another I’ve learned the hard way. It is rare I will make a decision where the group of advisors I have recruited have advised otherwise. In fact, I look for unanimous consensus.

Again, as a leader, there have been a few times I had to make decisions no one else could see at the time, but those were always times I was confident God was calling me to do something. (Such as in the conclusion to the David story I mentioned previously.) Short of this confirmation I depend on the wisdom of collective voices.

You are making the decision too quickly.

Some decisions, especially the major ones, need time to gel in your mind and heart. Most major decisions need a good nights sleep – or several good nights sleep. If you’re being rushed into the decision, you’ll likely make some mistakes.

Of course, there are times you have to move swiftly. Whenever possible, though, give the process adequate time.

You are making the decision too slowly.

The opposite is true also. When you’ve wrestled with it long enough, and you know the right thing to do, some decisions just need to be made – even without having all the answers. I’ve been guilty of missing opportunities because I got locked in decision paralysis and didn’t make the call I already knew I should make.

Honestly, many times I stalled only because I knew the reaction to the decision would not necessarily be popular.

Your gut tells you otherwise.

You have a gut for a reason. Most likely it was developed over years of experience. It’s usually dangerous to completely ignore it.

Of course, the key is actually being self aware enough to consider these indicators. But next time you’re about to make a major decision, put your potential actions through this grid. I’m speaking from experience of many times making a bad leadership decision. It might help you avoid some of my mistakes and actually make better ones.

Check out my leadership podcast where we discuss issues of leadership nuggets in a practical way. Plus, check out the other Lifeway Leadership Podcasts.

Ron Edmondson

Author Ron Edmondson

More posts by Ron Edmondson